| 1960 | Foyt, Force, Freeland, Templeman, Russo, Wilson, Christie, Hartley | 13th | 0 | 0 |
| 1959 | Freeland, Weyant, Christie, Larson, Grim, Amick, Carter, Johnson, Russo, Daywalt, Arnold, McWithey, Ward | 10th | 0 | 0 |
| 1958 | Goldsmith, Magill, Sutton, Russo, Thomson, O'Connor, Templeman, Veith, Christie, Garrett, Unser, Boyd, Johnson, Cheesbourg, Keller, Parsons | 8th | 0 | 0 |
| 1957 | Keller, Magill, Cheesbourg, Johnson, Agabashian, Reece, Daywalt, Elisian, Russo, Edmunds, George, Russo, Linden, Boyd, Teague, O'Connor, Turner, Christie, Bettenhausen, Parsons, Freeland | 6th | 0 | 0 |
| 1956 | Rathmann, Bettenhausen, Ruttman, Russo, Linden, Daywalt, Elisian, Boyd, Crawford, Herman, Andrews, Russo, Turner, Tolan, Hanks, Rathmann, Veith, Ward, Agabashian, Christie, Keller, Dinsmore, O'Connor | 3rd | 0 | 0 |
| 1955 | Keller, Agabashian, Parsons, McGrath, Hanks, Vukovich, Cross, Niday, Elisian, Boyd, Crawford, Sweikert, Bettenhausen, Russo, Davies, Faulkner, Homeier, Linden, Herman, O'Connor, Daywalt, Flaherty, Weyant | 4th | 0 | 1 |
| 1953 | Teague, Flaherty, Russo, Parsons, Hoyt, Webb, Hartley, Holmes, Niday, Vukovich, Cross, Hanks, Agabashian, McGrath, Daywalt, Rathmann, Johnson, Davies, Nalon, Scarborough, Holland, Ward, Dinsmore, Mantz, Faulkner | 3rd | 0 | 1 |
| 1952 | Scott, Ward, Agabashian, Hartley, Nalon, Linden, Miller, Sweikert, Rathmann, Hanks, Cross, Bryan, Reece, Connor, Griffith, Parsons, McGrath, Vukovich, Stevenson, McDowell | 3rd | 0 | 0 |
| 1951 | Ruttman, Agabashian, Green, Schindler, Parsons, Brown, Hanks, Nalon, Force, Scarborough, Griffith, Miller, Wallard, Nazaruk, McGrath, Ayulo, Forberg | 3rd | 0 | 0 |
| 1950 | Agabashian, Jackson, Hanks, Dinsmore, Parsons, Green, Chitwood, Faulkner, Flaherty, Hellings, McGrath, McDowell, Brown, Hoyt | 4th | 0 | 1 |